loosely-coupled-dss-extended/results/tables-stats.org

\begin{table*} \centering \caption{Simulation results using the shutdown on received strategy. Comparison between our previous results\cite{prev} are in color. Green indicates improvements, red shows regressions and blue indicates no change.} \begin{tabular}{crlllllll} \toprule \multirow{2}{*}{Uptime} & \multirow{2}{*}{Scenario} & \multirow{2}{*}{$\# Succ_p$} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{Energy Consumption (J)} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{$eOvhd(p)$ (\%)} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{$eff(p)$ (J)}\\ \cmidrule(lr){4-5}\cmidrule(lr){6-7}\cmidrule(lr){8-9} &&&Sender & Receiver&Sender & Receiver&Sender & Receiver\\ \midrule \multicolumn{9}{c}{LoRa}\\ \midrule \multirow{4}{*}{60}&baseline&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 764.49}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+147.12}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 578.68}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-2.45}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill --}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill --}\\ &extended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 22.89}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+16.87}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2115.26}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1110.9}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 593.32}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-18.74}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +176.69}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+114.01}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +2.53}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-2.79}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 92.43}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-74.41}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 25.93}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-75.74}}\\ &hint&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 788.4}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+159.66}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 704.39}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+118.32}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +3.13}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.29}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +21.72}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+20.87}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill --}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill --}\\ &hintandextended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 23.42}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+16.88}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2134.2}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1098.44}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 608.27}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-11.35}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +179.17}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+111.4}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +5.11}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-1.51}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 91.11}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-67.14}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 25.97}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-68.7}}\\ \midrule \multirow{4}{*}{180}&baseline&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 6.36}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+4.18}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2412.24}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+379.54}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1738.06}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-26.95}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 379.58}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-552.85}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 273.49}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-536.14}}\\ &extended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 46.8}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+35.94}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 4214.6}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+2013.01}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1749.29}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-17.71}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +74.72}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+66.41}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +0.65}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.53}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 90.06}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-112.76}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 37.38}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-125.4}}\\ &hint&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 22.78}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+11.61}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2418.8}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+287.12}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 3156.56}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1082.4}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +0.27}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-4.6}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +81.61}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+64.1}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 106.16}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-84.6}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 138.54}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-47.07}}\\ &hintandextended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 47.96}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+36.07}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 4297.84}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+2038.75}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2954.54}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1054.84}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +78.17}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+67.03}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +69.99}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+62.36}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 89.61}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-100.39}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 61.6}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-98.17}}\\ \midrule \multicolumn{9}{c}{NbIoT}\\ \midrule \multirow{4}{*}{60}&baseline&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 11.51}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+9.06}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1309.61}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+594.82}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 586.8}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-6.72}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 113.83}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-178.52}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 51}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-191.74}}\\ &extended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 38.19}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+31.81}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1723.51}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+962.68}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 587.42}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-3.86}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +31.61}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+25.16}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +0.11}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.48}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 45.14}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-74.12}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 15.38}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-77.29}}\\ &hint&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 22.78}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+17.98}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1500.26}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+728.4}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1086.98}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+472.17}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +14.56}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+6.57}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +85.24}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+81.65}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 65.86}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-94.78}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 47.72}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-80.24}}\\ &hintandextended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 47.65}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+40.06}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2006.18}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1215.33}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1007.15}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+396.96}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +53.19}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+42.55}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +71.64}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+68.83}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 42.1}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-62.09}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 21.14}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-59.26}}\\ \midrule \multirow{4}{*}{180}&baseline&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 71.2}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+60.84}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 3974.87}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1940.21}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1763.54}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-1.57}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 55.82}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-140.48}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 24.77}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-145.53}}\\ &extended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 84.7}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+73.59}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 4045.23}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+2019.02}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1751.24}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-1.59}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +1.77}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+2.19}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill -0.7}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 47.76}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-134.54}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 20.67}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-137.02}}\\ &hint&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 95.26}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+83.42}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 4520.49}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+2466.7}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2682.63}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+614.38}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +13.73}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+12.79}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +52.12}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+34.94}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 47.45}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-125.93}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 28.16}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-146.45}}\\ &hintandextended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 99}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+87.1}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 4459.94}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+2417.39}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2498.02}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+458.3}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +12.2}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+11.82}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +41.65}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+26.09}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 45.05}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-126.52}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 25.23}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-146.1}}\\ \bottomrule \end{tabular} \end{table*}