loosely-coupled-dss-extended/results/tables-stats.org

\begin{table*} \centering \caption{Simulation results using the shutdown on received strategy. Comparison between our previous results\cite{prev} are in color. Green indicates improvements, red shows regressions and blue indicates no change.} \begin{tabular}{crlllllll} \toprule \multirow{2}{*}{Uptime} & \multirow{2}{*}{Scenario} & \multirow{2}{*}{$\# Succ_p$} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{Energy Consumption (J)} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{$eOvhd(p)$ (\%)} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{$eff(p)$ (J)}\\ \cmidrule(lr){4-5}\cmidrule(lr){6-7}\cmidrule(lr){8-9} &&&Sender & Receiver&Sender & Receiver&Sender & Receiver\\ \midrule \multicolumn{9}{c}{LoRa}\\ \midrule \multirow{4}{*}{60}&baseline&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 617.4}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 581.1}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill --}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill --}\\ &extended&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 6}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 1004.4}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 612.1}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +62.7}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +5.3}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 166.8}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 101.7}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}\\ &hint&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 628.7}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 586.1}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +1.8}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +0.8}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill --}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill --}\\ &hintandextended&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 6.5}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 1035.8}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 619.6}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +67.8}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +6.6}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 158.3}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 94.7}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}\\ \midrule \multirow{4}{*}{180}&baseline&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 2.2}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 2032.7}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 1764}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-1}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 932.4}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 809.2}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.4}}\\ &extended&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 10.9}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 2201.6}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 1764.1}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-2.9}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +8.3}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 202.8}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 162.5}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.3}}\\ &hint&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 10.8}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{-0.4}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 2133}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.4}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 2029}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-45.2}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +4.9}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.1}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +15}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.1}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 197.6}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+6.8}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 188}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+2.4}}\\ &hintandextended&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 11.8}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{-0.1}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 2251.6}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-7.5}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 1879.7}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-20}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +10.8}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.4}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +6.6}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.4}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 190}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 158.6}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-1.2}}\\ \midrule \multicolumn{9}{c}{NbIoT}\\ \midrule \multirow{4}{*}{60}&baseline&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 2.4}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 714.8}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 592.3}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-1.2}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 292.3}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 242.2}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.5}}\\ &extended&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 6.4}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 760.8}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 589}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-2.3}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +6.4}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill -0.6}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 119.3}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 92.3}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.4}}\\ &hint&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 4.7}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{-0.1}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 777.9}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+6}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 608.4}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-6.4}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +8.8}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.8}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +2.7}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.8}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 165.9}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+5.3}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 129.7}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.7}}\\ &hintandextended&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 7.3}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{-0.3}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 785.9}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-4.9}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 603}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-7.2}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +10}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.7}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +1.8}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.7}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 107.3}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+3.1}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 82.3}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.9}}\\ \midrule \multirow{4}{*}{180}&baseline&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 10.4}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 2034.7}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 1729.6}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-35.5}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 196.3}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 166.9}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-3.4}}\\ &extended&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 11.1}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 2026.2}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 1717.5}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-35.3}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill -0.4}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill -0.7}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 182.3}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 154.5}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-3.2}}\\ &hint&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 11.8}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 2054.1}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.3}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 1937.3}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-131}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +1}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +12}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 174.2}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.8}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 164.3}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-10.3}}\\ &hintandextended&\makebox[0.4cm]{\hfill 11.8}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{-0.1}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 2041.5}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-1.1}}&\makebox[0.75cm]{\hfill 1916.3}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-123.4}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +0.3}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.1}}&\makebox[0.6cm]{\hfill +10.8}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.1}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 172.4}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.8}}&\makebox[0.55cm]{\hfill 161.8}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-9.5}}\\ \bottomrule \end{tabular} \end{table*}