Improve scenarios and analysis

results/analysis.R

@@ -1,10 +1,17 @@
 library("tidyverse")
-
+library("knitr")
 
 data=read_csv("results.csv")
 
-final=data%>%group_by(simkey)%>%summarize(energy=mean(energy),sd=sd(energy))
+final=data%>%group_by(simkey,wireless,wakeupfor)%>%summarize(energy=mean(energy),wireless=first(wireless),sd=sd(energy),wakeupfor=first(wakeupfor))
 
-ggplot(final,aes(x=simkey,y=energy))+geom_bar(stat="identity")+
-    xlab("Scenario")+ylab("Energy (J)")+
-     geom_errorbar(aes(ymin=energy-sd, ymax=energy+sd),width=.2,size=1.5) 
+ggplot(final,aes(x=simkey,y=energy))+
+    geom_bar(stat="identity",aes(fill=wireless),position=position_dodge())+
+    xlab("Scenarios")+ylab("Energy (J)")+
+    geom_errorbar(aes(ymin=energy-sd, ymax=energy+sd),width=.2,size=1.5) +
+    facet_wrap(~ wakeupfor) 
+
+for(wake in unique(data$wakeupfor)){
+    print(kable(final%>%filter(wireless=="lora",wakeupfor==wake)))
+    print(kable(final%>%filter(wireless!="lora",wakeupfor==wake)))
+}

results/paper.sh

@@ -8,68 +8,102 @@ inputs="${wai}/../inputs.json"
 simulator="make -C ${wai}/../ run"
 parser="${wai}/../parser.awk"
 results="${wai}/results.csv"
-nseed=20
+aheaders="simkey,wireless,wakeupfor"
+avalues="none,none,none"
 
 run-simulation () {
     # Generate inputs
-    $scenarios $seed $simtime $wakeupsd $wakeupevery $wakeupfor $n_nodes $extended $hint $poff $pon $prx $ptx $datasize $simkey > "$inputs"
+    $scenarios $seed $simtime $wakeupevery $wakeupfor $n_nodes $extended $hint $poff $pon $prx $ptx $datasize $bitrate > "$inputs"
     # Run simulations
-    [ -e "$results" ] && { $simulator 2>&1 | $parser | sed 1d >> "$results"; } || { $simulator 2>&1 | $parser > "$results"; }
+    if [ -e "$results" ]
+    then
+        $simulator 2>&1 | $parser | sed 1d | sed "s/$/,${avalues}/" >> "$results"
+    else
+        $simulator 2>&1 | $parser | sed "1 s/$/,${aheaders}/g" | sed "2,\$s/$/,${avalues}/" > "$results"
+    fi
 }
 
 # Default Parameters
 seed=0
-simtime=7200
-wakeupsd=180
-wakeupevery=600
+simtime=86400 # One day
+wakeupevery=3600
 wakeupfor=180
-n_nodes=5
+n_nodes=12
 extended="false"
 hint="false"
 poff=0
 pon=0.4
 prx=0.16
 ptx=0.16
-datasize=1000000
-simkey=0
+datasize=1000000 # MB
+bitrate="100kbps"
 
-# Baseline
-echo "Baseline..."
+run-scenarios() {
+    # Configure number of seed per scenarios
+    nseed=10
+
+    # Baseline
+    echo "Baseline..."
+    avalues="baseline,$wireless,$wakeupfor"
+    for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
+    do
+        run-simulation
+    done
+
+    # Hint
+    echo "Hint..."
+    hint="true"
+    avalues="hint,$wireless,$wakeupfor"
+    for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
+    do
+        run-simulation
+    done
+    hint="false"
+
+    # Extended
+    echo "Extended..."
+    extended="true"
+    avalues="extended,$wireless,$wakeupfor"
+    for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
+    do
+        run-simulation
+    done
+    extended="false"
+
+    # Hint+Extended
+    echo "Hint + Extended..."
+    extended="true"
+    hint="true"
+    avalues="hintandextended,$wireless,$wakeupfor"
+    for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
+    do
+        run-simulation
+    done
+    extended="false"
+    hint="false"
+}
+
+# Clean previous runs
 [ -e "${results}" ] && rm "${results}"
-simkey="baseline"
-for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
-do
-    run-simulation
-done
 
-# Hint
-echo "Hint..."
-hint="true"
-simkey="hint"
-for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
+for wakeupfor in 60 180
 do
-    run-simulation
-done
-hint="false"
 
-# Extended
-echo "Extended..."
-extended="true"
-simkey="extended"
-for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
-do
-    run-simulation
-done
-extended="false"
+    # Lora
+    echo "----- Run Lora ($wakeupfor) -----"
+    wireless="lora"
+    bitrate="50kbps"
+    pon=0.4
+    prx=0.16
+    ptx=0.16
+    run-scenarios
 
-# Hint+Extended
-echo "Hint + Extended..."
-extended="true"
-hint="true"
-simkey="hintandextended"
-for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
-do
-    run-simulation
-done
-extended="false"
-hint="false"
+    # NbIot
+    echo "----- Run NbIoT ($wakeupfor) -----"
+    wireless="nbiot"
+    bitrate="200kbps"
+    pon=0.4
+    prx=0.65
+    ptx=0.65
+    run-scenarios
+done

src/Inputs.cc

@@ -17,7 +17,6 @@ Inputs::Inputs(std::string node_name){
     use_hint=d["nodes"][node_name.c_str()]["use_hint"].GetBool();
     data_size=d["nodes"][node_name.c_str()]["data_size"].GetInt();
     extended=d["extended"].GetBool();
-    simkey=d["simkey"].GetString();
     seed=d["seed"].GetInt();
     n_nodes=d["nodes"].MemberCount();
 
@@ -156,7 +155,7 @@ void Inputs::GeneratePlatform(std::string p){
     pf << "<?xml version='1.0'?>\n";
     pf << "<!DOCTYPE platform SYSTEM \"http://simgrid.gforge.inria.fr/simgrid/simgrid.dtd\">\n";
     pf << "<platform version=\"4.1\">\n    <AS id=\"AS0\" routing=\"Cluster\">\n";
-    pf << "    <link id=\"link\" bandwidth=\"1Mbps\" latency=\"0ms\" sharing_policy=\"SHARED\"></link>\n";
+    pf << "    <link id=\"link\" bandwidth=\""<<d["bitrate"].GetString()<<"\" latency=\"0ms\" sharing_policy=\"SHARED\"></link>\n";
     for (Value::ConstMemberIterator itr = d["nodes"].MemberBegin(); itr != d["nodes"].MemberEnd(); ++itr)
     {
         std::string name=itr->name.GetString();

src/Inputs.hpp

@@ -79,6 +79,4 @@ public:
     int data_size;
     int seed;
     int n_nodes;
-    std::string simkey;
-
 };

src/scenarios.cc

@@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ using namespace rapidjson;
 
 int main(int argc, char **argv){
     // Setup seed
-    if(argc!=15){
+    if(argc!=14){
         cerr << "Usage: " << argv[0] <<
-            " <seed> <simtime> <wakeupsd> <wakeupevery> <wakeupfor> <n_nodes>" <<
-            " <extended> <hint> <poff> <pon> <prx> <ptx> <datasize> <simkey>" <<
+            " <seed> <simtime> <wakeupevery> <wakeupfor> <n_nodes>" <<
+            " <extended> <hint> <poff> <pon> <prx> <ptx> <datasize> <bitrate>" <<
             endl;
         exit(1);
     }
@@ -28,18 +28,18 @@ int main(int argc, char **argv){
     // Init parameters
     int seed=atoi(argv[1]);
     double simtime=stod(argv[2]);
-    unsigned int wakeupsd=atoi(argv[3]);
-    unsigned int wakeupevery=atoi(argv[4]);
-    double wakeupfor=stod(argv[5]);
-    unsigned int n_nodes=atoi(argv[6]);
-    bool extended=!strcmp("true",argv[7]);
-    bool hint=!strcmp("true",argv[8]);
-    double poff=stod(argv[9]);
-    double pon=stod(argv[10]);
-    double prx=stod(argv[11]);
-    double ptx=stod(argv[12]);
-    unsigned int datasize=atoi(argv[13]);
-    string simkey(argv[14]);
+    unsigned int wakeupevery=atoi(argv[3]);
+    double wakeupfor=stod(argv[4]);
+    unsigned int n_nodes=atoi(argv[5]);
+    bool extended=!strcmp("true",argv[6]);
+    bool hint=!strcmp("true",argv[7]);
+    double poff=stod(argv[8]);
+    double pon=stod(argv[9]);
+    double prx=stod(argv[10]);
+    double ptx=stod(argv[11]);
+    unsigned int datasize=atoi(argv[12]);
+    string bitrate(argv[13]);
+
 
     // Setup seed
     srand(seed);
@@ -47,10 +47,10 @@ int main(int argc, char **argv){
     // Create document
     Document d;
     d.SetObject();
-    Value simkeyValue;
-    simkeyValue.SetString(simkey.c_str(),simkey.size(),d.GetAllocator());
-    d.AddMember("simkey",simkeyValue,d.GetAllocator());
     d.AddMember("seed",Value().SetInt(seed),d.GetAllocator());
+    Value simkeyValue;
+    simkeyValue.SetString(bitrate.c_str(),bitrate.size(),d.GetAllocator());
+    d.AddMember("bitrate",simkeyValue,d.GetAllocator());
     d.AddMember("extended",extended,d.GetAllocator());
 
     // Create nodes
@@ -69,8 +69,8 @@ int main(int argc, char **argv){
         // Setup ts and durations
         Value ts(kArrayType);
         Value duration(kArrayType);
-        for(unsigned int i=0;(i+wakeupfor)<simtime;i+=RAND(wakeupevery-wakeupsd,wakeupevery+wakeupsd)){
-            ts.PushBack(Value().SetDouble(i),d.GetAllocator());
+        for(unsigned int i=0;i<simtime;i+=wakeupevery){
+            ts.PushBack(Value().SetDouble(RAND(i,i+wakeupevery)),d.GetAllocator());
             duration.PushBack(Value().SetDouble(wakeupfor),d.GetAllocator());
         }
         node.AddMember("wake_ts",ts,d.GetAllocator());

src/simulator.cc

@@ -183,5 +183,5 @@ static void obs_node(std::vector<std::string> args) {
     }
     // Done
     MODE_OFF()
-    XBT_INFO("Observation node %s finished [LOG2PARSE](node:%s|nSend:%d|nWakeUp:%d|nDataRcv:%d|nSendFail:%d|nRcvFail:%d|simkey:%s|seed:%d)",selfName.c_str(),selfName.c_str(),nSend,nWakeUp,nDataRcv,nSendFail,nRcvFail,i.simkey.c_str(),i.seed);
+    XBT_INFO("Observation node %s finished [LOG2PARSE](node:%s|nSend:%d|nWakeUp:%d|nDataRcv:%d|nSendFail:%d|nRcvFail:%d|seed:%d)",selfName.c_str(),selfName.c_str(),nSend,nWakeUp,nDataRcv,nSendFail,nRcvFail,i.seed);
 }