loic/loosely-coupled-dss-extended
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://gitlab.com/manzerbredes/loosely-coupled-dss-extended.git synced 2025-04-05 19:16:26 +02:00
Code Issues Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

Add CCGrid results and debug

Browse source
This commit is contained in:
Loic Guegan 2021-05-31 08:16:09 +02:00
parent 7f83a84d2d
commit 84d9ce59ae
11 changed files with 218 additions and 25 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

26
results/analysis.R
View file

@ -1,7 +1,9 @@
library("tidyverse")
library("knitr")
data=read_csv("results.csv")
data=read_csv("results.csv")
ccgrid=read_csv("ccgrid.csv")
r_=function(x){round(x,digits=2)}
@ -30,11 +32,32 @@ receiverUptime=data%>%filter(isSender==0)%>%group_by(simkey,wireless,wakeupfor)%
finalStats=finalStats%>%left_join(senderUptime,by=c("simkey","wireless","wakeupfor"))
finalStats=finalStats%>%left_join(receiverUptime,by=c("simkey","wireless","wakeupfor"))
# Comparison
finalStats=finalStats%>%left_join(ccgrid,by=c("simkey","wireless","wakeupfor"),suffix = c("","_ccgrid"))
finalStats=finalStats%>%mutate(senderEnergy_err=abs(r_((senderEnergy-senderEnergy_ccgrid)/senderEnergy)*100))
finalStats=finalStats%>%mutate(receiverEnergy_err=abs(r_((receiverEnergy-receiverEnergy_ccgrid)/receiverEnergy)*100))
finalStats=finalStats%>%mutate(senderUptime_err=abs(r_((senderUptime-senderUptime_ccgrid)/senderUptime)*100))
finalStats=finalStats%>%mutate(receiverUptime_err=abs(r_((receiverUptime-receiverUptime_ccgrid)/receiverUptime)*100))
# Add nSendFail to stats
sendFail=data%>%filter(node=="on0")%>%group_by(simkey,wireless,wakeupfor)%>%summarise(nSendFail=mean(nSendFail))
finalStats=finalStats%>%left_join(sendFail,by=c("simkey","wireless","wakeupfor"))
ggplot(finalStats,aes(x=simkey,senderEnergy_err,color=wireless,group=wireless))+geom_point()+geom_line()+facet_wrap(~wakeupfor)+xlab("Scenarios") + ylab("Sender Energy Relative Error (%)") + expand_limits(x = 0, y = 0)
ggsave("err_sender_energy.png",width=7,height = 5)
ggplot(finalStats,aes(x=simkey,receiverEnergy_err,color=wireless,group=wireless))+geom_point()+geom_line()+facet_wrap(~wakeupfor)+xlab("Scenarios") + ylab("Receiver Energy Relative Error (%)") + expand_limits(x = 0, y = 0)
ggsave("err_receiver_energy.png",width=7,height = 5)
ggplot(finalStats,aes(x=simkey,senderUptime_err,color=wireless,group=wireless))+geom_point()+geom_line()+facet_wrap(~wakeupfor)+xlab("Scenarios") + ylab("Sender AccUptime Energy Relative Error (%)") + expand_limits(x = 0, y = 0)
ggsave("err_sender_accuptime.png",width=7,height = 5)
ggplot(finalStats,aes(x=simkey,receiverUptime_err,color=wireless,group=wireless))+geom_point()+geom_line()+facet_wrap(~wakeupfor)+xlab("Scenarios") + ylab("Receiver AccUptime Energy Relative Error (%)") + expand_limits(x = 0, y = 0)
ggsave("err_rcv_accuptime.png",width=7,height = 5)
stopifnot(1)
# Generate plots
ggplot(finalEnergy,aes(x=simkey,y=energy,fill=wireless))+
geom_bar(stat="identity",position=position_dodge())+
@ -57,6 +80,7 @@ ggplot(finalStats,aes(x=simkey,y=success,fill=wireless))+
facet_wrap(~ wakeupfor) +
ggsave("success.png")
##### Save tables #####
tf="tables-energy.org"
write("",file=tf)
for(wake in unique(data$wakeupfor)){

17
results/ccgrid.csv Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
simkey,wireless,wakeupfor,sd_success,success,senderEnergy,receiverEnergy,senderUptime,receiverUptime
baseline,lora,60,0,0,619.73,579.84,1440,1440
extended,lora,60,2,7.70,1207.61,627.35,2564.53,1523.52
hint,lora,60,0,0,753.42,957.64,1440,2354.94
hintandextended,lora,60,2.20,9.80,1397.98,663.58,2904.50,1602.39
baseline,nbiot,60,1.12,1.27,749.69,591.07,1440,1440
extended,nbiot,60,1.80,7.16,946.39,599.13,1788.32,1447.54
hint,nbiot,60,3.45,9.72,1007.06,702.59,1440,1666.51
hintandextended,nbiot,60,2.36,9.41,1066.66,623.30,1901.47,1492.53
baseline,lora,180,1.40,1.91,2026.23,1755.92,4320,4320
extended,lora,180,0.70,11.45,2692.46,1772.35,6038.78,4364.27
hint,lora,180,0,12, 2094.09,2169.50,4320,5344.86
hintandextended,lora,180,0.24,11.94,2757.79,1867.34,6155.50,4600.09
baseline,nbiot,180,1.33,9.90,2117.65,1761.78,4320,4320
extended,nbiot,180,0.87,11.23,2311.52,1760.92,4868.78,4323.71
hint,nbiot,180,0.37,11.92,2180.07,1868.54,4320,4576.83
hintandextended,nbiot,180,0.41,11.88,2151.14,1822.44,4906.10,4473.32
1 simkey wireless wakeupfor sd_success success senderEnergy receiverEnergy senderUptime receiverUptime
2 baseline lora 60 0 0 619.73 579.84 1440 1440
3 extended lora 60 2 7.70 1207.61 627.35 2564.53 1523.52
4 hint lora 60 0 0 753.42 957.64 1440 2354.94
5 hintandextended lora 60 2.20 9.80 1397.98 663.58 2904.50 1602.39
6 baseline nbiot 60 1.12 1.27 749.69 591.07 1440 1440
7 extended nbiot 60 1.80 7.16 946.39 599.13 1788.32 1447.54
8 hint nbiot 60 3.45 9.72 1007.06 702.59 1440 1666.51
9 hintandextended nbiot 60 2.36 9.41 1066.66 623.30 1901.47 1492.53
10 baseline lora 180 1.40 1.91 2026.23 1755.92 4320 4320
11 extended lora 180 0.70 11.45 2692.46 1772.35 6038.78 4364.27
12 hint lora 180 0 12 2094.09 2169.50 4320 5344.86
13 hintandextended lora 180 0.24 11.94 2757.79 1867.34 6155.50 4600.09
14 baseline nbiot 180 1.33 9.90 2117.65 1761.78 4320 4320
15 extended nbiot 180 0.87 11.23 2311.52 1760.92 4868.78 4323.71
16 hint nbiot 180 0.37 11.92 2180.07 1868.54 4320 4576.83
17 hintandextended nbiot 180 0.41 11.88 2151.14 1822.44 4906.10 4473.32

BIN
results/energy.png
View file

Binary file not shown.
Side by side Swipe Overlay

Before

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 267 KiB

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 295 KiB

BIN
results/err_rcv_accuptime.png Normal file
View file

Binary file not shown.
Side by side

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 122 KiB

BIN
results/err_receiver_energy.png Normal file
View file

Binary file not shown.
Side by side

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 115 KiB

BIN
results/err_sender_accuptime.png Normal file
View file

Binary file not shown.
Side by side

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 160 KiB

BIN
results/err_sender_energy.png Normal file
View file

Binary file not shown.
Side by side

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 136 KiB

139
results/paper_.sh Executable file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,139 @@
#!/usr/bin/env bash
set -e
wai=$(dirname $(readlink -f "$0"))
scenarios="${wai}/../scenarios"
inputs="${wai}/../inputs.json"
simulator="make -C ${wai}/../ run"
parser="${wai}/../parser.awk"
results="${wai}/results_.csv"
aheaders="simkey,wireless,wakeupfor"
avalues="none,none,none"
log_file="${wai}/logs/$(date +%s)_.org" && mkdir -p "${wai}/logs/"
gen_log=1 # Should we generate logs ?
run-simulation () {
# Generate inputs
$scenarios $seed $simtime $wakeupevery $wakeupfor $n_nodes $extended $hint $poff $pon $prx $ptx $datasize $bitrate $hintsize $latency > "$inputs"
# Init logs
[ $gen_log -eq 1 ] && echo -e "* seed=$seed simtime=$simtime wakeupevery=$wakeupevery wakeupfor=$wakeupfor n_nodes=$n_nodes extended=$extended hint=$hint poff=$poff pon=$pon prx=$prx ptx=$ptx datasize=$datasize bitrate=$bitrate \n" >> "${log_file}"
# Run simulations
if [ -e "$results" ]
then
# Create new result file
if [ $gen_log -eq 1 ]
then
$simulator 2>&1 | tee -a "${log_file}" | $parser | sed 1d | sed "s/$/,${avalues}/" >> "$results"
else
$simulator 2>&1 | $parser | sed 1d | sed "s/$/,${avalues}/" >> "$results"
fi
else
# Use existing result file
if [ $gen_log -eq 1 ]
then
$simulator 2>&1 | tee -a "${log_file}" | $parser | sed "1 s/$/,${aheaders}/g" | sed "2,\$s/$/,${avalues}/" > "$results"
else
$simulator 2>&1 | $parser | sed "1 s/$/,${aheaders}/g" | sed "2,\$s/$/,${avalues}/" > "$results"
fi
fi
}
# Default Parameters
seed=1
simtime=86400 # One day
wakeupevery=3600
wakeupfor=60
n_nodes=12
extended="false"
hint="false"
poff=0
pon=0.4
prx=0.16
ptx=0.16
datasize=1000000 # 1Mb
hintsize=8 # Integer
latency=0 # in Seconds
bitrate="100kbps"
run-scenarios() {
# Configure number of seed per scenarios
nseed=1
# Baseline
avalues="baseline,$wireless,$wakeupfor"
for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
do
printf "\rBaseline...${seed}"
#run-simulation
done
echo
# Hint
hint="true"
avalues="hint,$wireless,$wakeupfor"
for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
do
printf "\rHint...${seed}"
run-simulation
done
hint="false"
echo
# Extended
extended="true"
avalues="extended,$wireless,$wakeupfor"
for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
do
printf "\rExtended...${seed}"
#run-simulation
done
extended="false"
echo
# Hint+Extended
extended="true"
hint="true"
avalues="hintandextended,$wireless,$wakeupfor"
for seed in $(seq 1 $nseed)
do
printf "\rHint + Extended...${seed}"
#run-simulation
done
extended="false"
hint="false"
echo
}
# Clean previous runs
[ -e "${results}" ] && rm "${results}"
for wakeupfor in 60
do
# Lora
echo "----- Run Lora (wakeupfor=$wakeupfor) -----"
wireless="lora"
bitrate="50kbps"
pon=0.4
prx=0.16
ptx=0.16
latency=0
#run-scenarios
# NbIot
echo "----- Run NbIoT (wakeupfor=$wakeupfor) -----"
wireless="nbiot"
bitrate="200kbps"
pon=0.4
prx=0.65
ptx=0.65
latency=0.01
run-scenarios
done
echo "Logs: $log_file"

13
results/results_.csv Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
node,isSender,nSend,nWakeUp,nDataRcv,nSendFail,nRcvFail,totalUptime,seed,hint_added,energy,simkey,wireless,wakeupfor
on6,0,0,24,0,0,1428,1440.000000,1,0,584.450000,hint,nbiot,60
on9,0,0,24,0,0,1440,1440.000000,1,0,576.000000,hint,nbiot,60
on11,0,0,24,0,0,1420,1440.000000,1,0,589.650000,hint,nbiot,60
on8,0,0,24,1,0,439,1441.989680,1,0,606.052580,hint,nbiot,60
on2,0,0,24,1,0,483,1440.010320,1,0,602.010836,hint,nbiot,60
on10,0,0,24,0,0,1440,1440.000000,1,0,576.000000,hint,nbiot,60
on5,0,0,24,0,0,1431,1440.000000,1,0,582.500000,hint,nbiot,60
on3,0,0,24,0,0,1440,1440.000000,1,0,576.000000,hint,nbiot,60
on4,0,0,24,0,0,1440,1440.000000,1,0,576.000000,hint,nbiot,60
on1,0,0,24,0,0,1440,1440.000000,1,0,576.000000,hint,nbiot,60
on7,0,0,24,1,0,282,1494.979360,1,1,636.160160,hint,nbiot,60
on0,1,3,24,0,0,0,1440.000000,1,0,840.550000,hint,nbiot,60
1 node isSender nSend nWakeUp nDataRcv nSendFail nRcvFail totalUptime seed hint_added energy simkey wireless wakeupfor
2 on6 0 0 24 0 0 1428 1440.000000 1 0 584.450000 hint nbiot 60
3 on9 0 0 24 0 0 1440 1440.000000 1 0 576.000000 hint nbiot 60
4 on11 0 0 24 0 0 1420 1440.000000 1 0 589.650000 hint nbiot 60
5 on8 0 0 24 1 0 439 1441.989680 1 0 606.052580 hint nbiot 60
6 on2 0 0 24 1 0 483 1440.010320 1 0 602.010836 hint nbiot 60
7 on10 0 0 24 0 0 1440 1440.000000 1 0 576.000000 hint nbiot 60
8 on5 0 0 24 0 0 1431 1440.000000 1 0 582.500000 hint nbiot 60
9 on3 0 0 24 0 0 1440 1440.000000 1 0 576.000000 hint nbiot 60
10 on4 0 0 24 0 0 1440 1440.000000 1 0 576.000000 hint nbiot 60
11 on1 0 0 24 0 0 1440 1440.000000 1 0 576.000000 hint nbiot 60
12 on7 0 0 24 1 0 282 1494.979360 1 1 636.160160 hint nbiot 60
13 on0 1 3 24 0 0 0 1440.000000 1 0 840.550000 hint nbiot 60

BIN
results/success.png
View file

Binary file not shown.
Side by side Swipe Overlay

Before

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 185 KiB

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 220 KiB

48
results/tables-stats.org
View file

@ -1,33 +1,33 @@
|simkey |wireless | wakeupfor| sd_success| success| senderEnergy| receiverEnergy| senderUptime| receiverUptime| nSendFail|
|:---------------|:--------|---------:|----------:|-------:|------------:|--------------:|------------:|--------------:|---------:|
|baseline |lora | 60| 0.000000| 0.000| 632.3280| 581.1460| 1440.000| 1439.923| 0|
|extended |lora | 60| 1.505359| 5.735| 982.8520| 613.5576| 2090.090| 1500.527| 0|
|hint |lora | 60| 0.000000| 0.000| 641.9022| 585.4391| 1440.000| 1449.476| 0|
|hintandextended |lora | 60| 1.635282| 6.185| 1027.2315| 620.5401| 2129.752| 1513.171| 0|
|simkey |wireless | wakeupfor| sd_success| success| senderEnergy| receiverEnergy| senderUptime| receiverUptime| sd_success_ccgrid| success_ccgrid| senderEnergy_ccgrid| receiverEnergy_ccgrid| senderUptime_ccgrid| receiverUptime_ccgrid| senderEnergy_err| receiverEnergy_err| senderUptime_err| receiverUptime_err| nSendFail|
|:---------------|:--------|---------:|----------:|-------:|------------:|--------------:|------------:|--------------:|-----------------:|--------------:|-------------------:|---------------------:|-------------------:|---------------------:|----------------:|------------------:|----------------:|------------------:|---------:|
|baseline |lora | 60| 0.000000| 0.000| 632.3280| 581.1460| 1440.000| 1439.923| 0.0| 0.0| 619.73| 579.84| 1440.00| 1440.00| 2| 0| 0| 0| 0|
|extended |lora | 60| 1.505359| 5.735| 982.8520| 613.5576| 2090.090| 1500.527| 2.0| 7.7| 1207.61| 627.35| 2564.53| 1523.52| -23| -2| -23| -2| 0|
|hint |lora | 60| 0.000000| 0.000| 641.9022| 585.4391| 1440.000| 1449.476| 0.0| 0.0| 753.42| 957.64| 1440.00| 2354.94| -17| -64| 0| -62| 0|
|hintandextended |lora | 60| 1.635282| 6.185| 1027.2315| 620.5401| 2129.752| 1513.171| 2.2| 9.8| 1397.98| 663.58| 2904.50| 1602.39| -36| -7| -36| -6| 0|
|simkey |wireless | wakeupfor| sd_success| success| senderEnergy| receiverEnergy| senderUptime| receiverUptime| nSendFail|
|:---------------|:--------|---------:|----------:|-------:|------------:|--------------:|------------:|--------------:|---------:|
|baseline |nbiot | 60| 1.291633| 2.255| 787.9910| 593.6499| 1440.000| 1439.923| 0|
|extended |nbiot | 60| 1.585075| 6.010| 789.8257| 591.7123| 1482.840| 1443.758| 0|
|hint |nbiot | 60| 2.356878| 4.230| 881.7522| 610.6209| 1440.000| 1462.637| 0|
|hintandextended |nbiot | 60| 1.824016| 6.860| 907.3576| 606.1796| 1484.538| 1459.460| 0|
|simkey |wireless | wakeupfor| sd_success| success| senderEnergy| receiverEnergy| senderUptime| receiverUptime| sd_success_ccgrid| success_ccgrid| senderEnergy_ccgrid| receiverEnergy_ccgrid| senderUptime_ccgrid| receiverUptime_ccgrid| senderEnergy_err| receiverEnergy_err| senderUptime_err| receiverUptime_err| nSendFail|
|:---------------|:--------|---------:|----------:|-------:|------------:|--------------:|------------:|--------------:|-----------------:|--------------:|-------------------:|---------------------:|-------------------:|---------------------:|----------------:|------------------:|----------------:|------------------:|---------:|
|baseline |nbiot | 60| 1.291633| 2.255| 787.9910| 593.6499| 1440.000| 1439.923| 1.12| 1.27| 749.69| 591.07| 1440.00| 1440.00| 5| 0| 0| 0| 0|
|extended |nbiot | 60| 1.585075| 6.010| 789.8257| 591.7123| 1482.840| 1443.758| 1.80| 7.16| 946.39| 599.13| 1788.32| 1447.54| -20| -1| -21| 0| 0|
|hint |nbiot | 60| 2.356878| 4.230| 881.7522| 610.6209| 1440.000| 1462.637| 3.45| 9.72| 1007.06| 702.59| 1440.00| 1666.51| -14| -15| 0| -14| 0|
|hintandextended |nbiot | 60| 1.824016| 6.860| 907.3576| 606.1796| 1484.538| 1459.460| 2.36| 9.41| 1066.66| 623.30| 1901.47| 1492.53| -18| -3| -28| -2| 0|
|simkey |wireless | wakeupfor| sd_success| success| senderEnergy| receiverEnergy| senderUptime| receiverUptime| nSendFail|
|:---------------|:--------|---------:|----------:|-------:|------------:|--------------:|------------:|--------------:|---------:|
|baseline |lora | 180| 1.255250| 1.835| 2101.411| 1764.778| 4319.945| 4317.934| 0|
|extended |lora | 180| 1.104752| 9.825| 2168.013| 1765.011| 4761.910| 4355.365| 0|
|hint |lora | 180| 1.522858| 10.050| 2195.374| 2015.582| 4319.945| 4832.081| 0|
|hintandextended |lora | 180| 0.562456| 10.735| 2318.551| 1869.760| 4791.917| 4543.989| 0|
|simkey |wireless | wakeupfor| sd_success| success| senderEnergy| receiverEnergy| senderUptime| receiverUptime| sd_success_ccgrid| success_ccgrid| senderEnergy_ccgrid| receiverEnergy_ccgrid| senderUptime_ccgrid| receiverUptime_ccgrid| senderEnergy_err| receiverEnergy_err| senderUptime_err| receiverUptime_err| nSendFail|
|:---------------|:--------|---------:|----------:|-------:|------------:|--------------:|------------:|--------------:|-----------------:|--------------:|-------------------:|---------------------:|-------------------:|---------------------:|----------------:|------------------:|----------------:|------------------:|---------:|
|baseline |lora | 180| 1.255250| 1.835| 2101.411| 1764.778| 4319.945| 4317.934| 1.40| 1.91| 2026.23| 1755.92| 4320.00| 4320.00| 4| 1| 0| 0| 0|
|extended |lora | 180| 1.104752| 9.825| 2168.013| 1765.011| 4761.910| 4355.365| 0.70| 11.45| 2692.46| 1772.35| 6038.78| 4364.27| -24| 0| -27| 0| 0|
|hint |lora | 180| 1.522858| 10.050| 2195.374| 2015.582| 4319.945| 4832.081| 0.00| 12.00| 2094.09| 2169.50| 4320.00| 5344.86| 5| -8| 0| -11| 0|
|hintandextended |lora | 180| 0.562456| 10.735| 2318.551| 1869.760| 4791.917| 4543.989| 0.24| 11.94| 2757.79| 1867.34| 6155.50| 4600.09| -19| 0| -28| -1| 0|
|simkey |wireless | wakeupfor| sd_success| success| senderEnergy| receiverEnergy| senderUptime| receiverUptime| nSendFail|
|:---------------|:--------|---------:|----------:|-------:|------------:|--------------:|------------:|--------------:|---------:|
|baseline |nbiot | 180| 1.2720418| 9.200| 2582.264| 1766.027| 4319.945| 4317.934| 0|
|extended |nbiot | 180| 1.0582887| 9.975| 2456.997| 1751.549| 4343.803| 4319.913| 0|
|hint |nbiot | 180| 0.6046512| 10.715| 2971.540| 1996.878| 4319.945| 4501.213| 0|
|hintandextended |nbiot | 180| 0.5713204| 10.735| 2949.652| 1975.150| 4334.482| 4482.790| 0|
|simkey |wireless | wakeupfor| sd_success| success| senderEnergy| receiverEnergy| senderUptime| receiverUptime| sd_success_ccgrid| success_ccgrid| senderEnergy_ccgrid| receiverEnergy_ccgrid| senderUptime_ccgrid| receiverUptime_ccgrid| senderEnergy_err| receiverEnergy_err| senderUptime_err| receiverUptime_err| nSendFail|
|:---------------|:--------|---------:|----------:|-------:|------------:|--------------:|------------:|--------------:|-----------------:|--------------:|-------------------:|---------------------:|-------------------:|---------------------:|----------------:|------------------:|----------------:|------------------:|---------:|
|baseline |nbiot | 180| 1.2720418| 9.200| 2582.264| 1766.027| 4319.945| 4317.934| 1.33| 9.90| 2117.65| 1761.78| 4320.00| 4320.00| 18| 0| 0| 0| 0|
|extended |nbiot | 180| 1.0582887| 9.975| 2456.997| 1751.549| 4343.803| 4319.913| 0.87| 11.23| 2311.52| 1760.92| 4868.78| 4323.71| 6| -1| -12| 0| 0|
|hint |nbiot | 180| 0.6046512| 10.715| 2971.540| 1996.878| 4319.945| 4501.213| 0.37| 11.92| 2180.07| 1868.54| 4320.00| 4576.83| 27| 6| 0| -2| 0|
|hintandextended |nbiot | 180| 0.5713204| 10.735| 2949.652| 1975.150| 4334.482| 4482.790| 0.41| 11.88| 2151.14| 1822.44| 4906.10| 4473.32| 27| 8| -13| 0| 0|