
\begin{table*}
\centering
\caption{Simulation results using the shutdown on received strategy. Comparison between our previous results\cite{prev} are in color. Green indicates improvements, red shows regressions and blue indicates no change.}
\begin{tabular}{crlllllll}
\toprule
\multirow{2}{*}{Uptime} & \multirow{2}{*}{Scenario} & \multirow{2}{*}{$\# Succ_p$} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{Energy Consumption (J)} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{$eOvhd(p)$ (\%)} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{$eff(p)$ (J)}\\
\cmidrule(lr){4-5}\cmidrule(lr){6-7}\cmidrule(lr){8-9}
&&&Sender & Receiver&Sender & Receiver&Sender & Receiver\\
\midrule
\multicolumn{9}{c}{LoRa}\\
\midrule
\multirow{4}{*}{60}&baseline&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 617.37}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 581.14}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill --}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill --}\\
&extended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 6.02}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1004.36}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 612.06}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +62.68}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +5.32}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 166.84}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 101.67}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}\\
&hint&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 628.74}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 586.07}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +1.84}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +0.85}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill --}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill --}\\
&hintandextended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 8.05}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+1.51}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1130.67}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+94.91}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 639.55}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+19.93}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +83.14}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+15.37}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +10.05}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+3.43}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 140.37}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-17.88}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 79.4}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-15.27}}\\
\midrule
\multirow{4}{*}{180}&baseline&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 2.18}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2032.69}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1764.97}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.04}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 932.43}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 809.62}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.02}}\\
&extended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 10.86}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2201.59}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1766.76}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.24}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +8.31}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +0.1}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.01}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 202.82}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 162.76}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.02}}\\
&hint&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 11.57}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+0.39}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2136.67}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+5}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2096.91}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+22.75}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +5.12}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.25}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +18.81}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.29}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 184.67}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-6.08}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 181.24}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-4.37}}\\
&hintandextended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 11.97}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+0.08}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2280.6}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+21.51}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1926.49}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+26.79}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +12.2}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.06}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +9.15}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.52}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 190.53}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.53}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 160.94}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.17}}\\
\midrule
\multicolumn{9}{c}{NbIoT}\\
\midrule
\multirow{4}{*}{60}&baseline&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 2.44}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 714.79}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 593.47}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.05}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 292.35}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 242.73}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.02}}\\
&extended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 6.38}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 760.83}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 591.14}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.14}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +6.44}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill -0.39}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.02}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 119.25}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 92.65}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.02}}\\
&hint&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 6.11}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+1.31}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 821.32}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+49.46}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 627.96}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+13.15}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +14.9}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+6.92}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +5.81}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+2.22}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 134.42}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-26.21}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 102.78}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-25.18}}\\
&hintandextended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 9.82}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+2.23}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 858.74}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+67.89}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 635.36}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+25.17}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +20.14}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+9.5}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +7.06}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+4.25}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 87.45}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-16.75}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 64.7}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-15.69}}\\
\midrule
\multirow{4}{*}{180}&baseline&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 10.37}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2034.67}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1761.97}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-3.14}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill 0}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 196.3}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 169.99}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.3}}\\
&extended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 11.12}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2026.21}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 1748.93}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-3.9}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill -0.42}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill -0.74}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.04}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 182.3}~{\color{blue!60}\textbf{=}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 157.35}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.35}}\\
&hint&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 11.96}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+0.12}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2055.21}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.43}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2028.09}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-40.16}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +1.01}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.07}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +15.1}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-2.07}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 171.84}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-1.55}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 169.57}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-5.04}}\\
&hintandextended&\makebox[0.5cm]{\hfill 11.97}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{+0.07}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2044.19}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+1.64}}&\makebox[0.8cm]{\hfill 2019.51}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-20.2}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +0.47}~{\color{red!60}\textbf{+0.08}}&\makebox[0.7cm]{\hfill +14.62}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.94}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 170.71}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-0.87}}&\makebox[0.65cm]{\hfill 168.64}~{\color{green!60}\textbf{-2.69}}\\
\bottomrule
\end{tabular}
\end{table*}
